arundhati and poonam live far from each other, in different countries, in different time zones. they share a common vision though. polio man is an attempt to explore that through a series of pieces on issues close to their hearts.

Saturday, November 12, 2005

little girls missing

after the minor fiasco on this page and the subsequent deletion of 2 posts, there was an urgent need to move on, to put up another post fast. and to do that, for some odd reason, we froze on female infanticide as the next topic. talking about this cause is never an easy task. i have gone through the pains (if i may) one time too many.

a year and a half ago, in a 5 pager review to my 2 long copy ads on female infanticide, a veteran ad writer/author based in UK, narrated this incident to me on mail.

“there was a particularly cruel experiment done once with monkeys, where a mother monkey and her baby were placed in a cage with a metal floor which was progressively heated. for a long time the mother monkey suffered the pain in her feet, but when the floor became so hot as to sear her feet she threw the baby on the floor and stood on it.”

what parents do to their own little girls in this country is equally unpalatable. here’s an excerpt from one of my ads, to give you an idea:

take a bath towel, dip it in a bucket full of cold water, bring it out, don't wring it, place it on the floor, bring a newborn baby girl, lay her down on the towel and wrap her in it. wait for a few minutes until she catches pneumonia and then don't treat it. result: death. for faster results, drown the baby in a pot of milk, or stuff her in a clay pot. you can even feed her grains of paddy husk, cooking salt or tobacco. when none of these are available, just hold the baby from the waist and shake her back and forth until the spinal cord snaps. she won’t have so much of chance to let out even a faint cry.

salt, tobacco, pot of milk, wet cold towel…household stuff or weaponry? think about it.

when i was researching on the cause, beside the staggering statistics, what alarmed me more was how these methods and codes (which i will talk about further in this para) traversed the length and the breadth of the country, merely on hushed whispers.
that squeezing the milky sap from an oleander shrub and mixing it with castor oil can produce poison, lethal enough to kill a newborn is common knowledge, possibly in more states than you and i know of.
that when a pregnant couple go to a doctor for an ultrasound test, the doc reveals (illegal) the sex of the baby by asking them to buy either pink clothes (which means a girl) or blue (which means a boy). or treat yourself to ladoos (girl), barfi (boy). the couple then leave the clinic only after they have reserved an appointment for a (sex selective) abortion. these methods and codes are common knowledge despite the fact they were never published, no one set them in any book as a rule, they weren’t even popular references, until now.

excerpt 2:
for centuries, dating as far back as the vedic era, the evil of female infanticide has been surreptitiously but effectively eroding the sense of humanity in parents and family patriarchs. the preference of a son over a daughter is so overbearing, even the frail body of their own just born daughter evokes contempt in the parents.

no wonder, UN states 50 million, read again 50 million girls have gone missing. that figure is more than the one of the biggest genocides in history, holocaust which is generally reckoned at six million jews.

on the other hand, the figure will not come as a surprise if you consider the number of the decades that have gone into it. but what will surprise is that this practice has been under wraps for such a long time. now what else can it be, if not a nationwide coup against the girl child. how many, really how many families are involved?

excerpt 3:
a daughter is considered an economic liability because of the heavy dowry demanded by the groom's family at the time of marriage. on the other hand, the birth of a son is perceived as an opportunity for upward mobility. sons are expected to support their parents in old age and are therefore viewed as a source of social security.

now consider this. there are reports on how in the affluent haryana, parents buy brides for their sons from neighbouring villages, some even from far-off states for a price, termed as dowry. this is a powerful irony, almost poetic, according to the senior who reviewed my ads. i concur.

excerpt 4:
the most adverse effect of this carnage can be seen in child sex ratios. the ideal child sex ratio is 1000 or more girls per 1000 boys. in 1991, it was an alarming 945 girls per 1000 boys. in 2001, it got worse. just 927 girls per 1000 boys. haryana has the lowest sex ratio in the country at 875 females per 1,000 males. neighbouring punjab stands closer at 882.

there are no reports yet, but there is caution about how men in these places where there is an acute scarcity of women, will turn to bestiality eventually. and if that begins to happen, if it has not already, we will hear of strange, alien diseases unknown to mankind before.

excerpt 5:
go to the farthest villages in rajasthan, up, maharashtra, haryana, punjab, gujarat, even bihar, you may not find clean drinking water but there is good chance you’d find a doctor wielding the latest technology that enables sex selective abortion. not only this, you’d find him advertising his services too. often as blatantly as ‘pay rs 500 now and save rs 50,000 (to be given as dowry to the daughter) later’.
in 1994, the indian government passed a bill banning the misuse of pre-natal diagnostic techniques. the directive permitted the doctors to use the equipment only to check on the unborn’s condition, not to check or reveal its sex. the bill is far from being implemented even today, 10 years later.


beside the doctors and the parents, there are local dais in villages who execute the job pretty well.

excerpt 6:
the less brutal of them pay the old midwives, called dais in local lingo, to get rid of the babies for a fee that ranges from rs 60-rs 150. the girls, who survive, often not for the love of their parents, are denied adequate nutrition. inadequate breast feeding and early weaning; insufficient or delayed medical care; lack of attention and emotional deprivation are just a few ways to ensure the girl dies a natural death in less than 6 years.

with this, i am done with the info bit of the post. am exhausted yet again and pretty much tongue-tied too. the whys of it all continue to escape me. dowry and son preference are cited to be the main reasons. i am not convinced. if dowry is one of the reasons then how does one explain pregnant NRI couples coming to india, getting to know the sex of the foetus, aborting it if it’s a girl and then back to where they came from. dowry should be the least of issues on their mind.
or how do you explain the imbalance in the sex ratio in bombay amongst the other cities. there is one doctor called dr malpani who runs a clinic in south bombay, is known to have made it big only by conducting sex selective abortions. google him if you want more info.
the ngo i volunteer with, played a role in getting to him but he is free and practicing even today, from what i know. infact, the ngo also filed a second PIL (the first one was filed sometime in the early 90s) in the supreme court in february 2000 to put the issue of sex determination and sex preselection on the national agenda.

if not dowry, is son preference such a strong motive. how cruel is it to prefer one child over the other, merely on basis of gender.
and isn’t it heartbreaking to know that for parents to stop killing their own daughters, we need PILs and laws.

it would be unrealistic to think that this practice can be eradiated completely, containing it is definitely possible. it needs a well-organised national campaign, no less. but one can make a small beginning atleast. if any one has ideas, i can introduce you to the right people. if not that, just talk about it, be angry about it, be concerned. that'll be something.

~ poonam

16 Comments:

Blogger Arundhati said...

My heart shudders, and the woman in me cries out. I am not sure if we are fortunate for we were "allowed" to live in this world or really unfortunate for we have to witness this carnage.

Still, I feel the problem is much bigger than this and infanticide is just a manifestation. Can we ever grasp the it in its entirity?

11:10 PM

 
Blogger Sundar said...

horrific..i have come across children being drowned in boiling oil...
yet we have come a long way in some pockets..i remember usilampatti in tamil nadu....the last few years, IACD has made good progress....but finally, somewhere issues have to be tackled deeper...addressals have to be multi-pronged...welfare and development oriented simultaneously...

2:09 AM

 
Blogger poonam said...

sundar: i have heard about usilampatti. what's IACD? arundhati tells me you consult with some non governmental institutions. would you be able to source some resource material, preferably audio visual, on infanticide. i'd be interested. i have been meaning to visit 'sparrow' for a long time now.

10:21 AM

 
Blogger Sundar said...

indian association for child development..hve come across their work during my association with CRY..am sure CRY doc centre should have some quality info on the issue...the CRY no, in BBY is 23093651...i remember IACD as a very innovative approaches organization..were supported through a CRY programme...
another individual i feel shd be of great "information and strategy resource" help would be Shanta Sinha, based in Hyderabad..she runs MV Foundation, a facility for children abused through bonded labour....she was a faculty at the University too...she is widely networked....and a very dynamic social thinker.. was awarded the padma shri a couple of years back...mebbe a very useful "connect"...her address could also be accessed through the CRY project support unit or doc centre at mumbai.....not sure who is there now...the girl in charge was lakshmi...if she is around , u can use my reference...ingrid srinath is the current ceo...the doc centre should also have other information media ....audio visuals etc....JOhn Cruz at C.E.D- Centre for education and development...also runs a documentation centre with facility for memebership, incase you are already not in touch...they are a regular source of information in regard to various issues...

5:07 PM

 
Blogger Sundar said...

oops ..that cry no shd read 23063651...the cry website is cry.org

7:09 PM

 
Blogger Anon said...

arundhati....very nice.I'd seen this movie 'Matrubhumi-a country with out women' and it really scared the hell out of me.I dunno how we are going to come out of this...or if we ever will.Sometimes i think abortion is better than getting those innocent little babies into the world and then denying then a dignified existence.

Also dont get me wrong, just try to type your blogs with propr formatting wit capitals and lot os space.It makes a world of a diffrence,trust me.Also you wre say, "In my ad..|.Could you tell me what that means.

8:49 PM

 
Blogger poonam said...

sundar: i can get enough printed resource material from CEHAT.
i need only audio visual. will look up john cruz at CED soon. thanks. :)

9:30 PM

 
Blogger poonam said...

komal: this post is written by me, i forgot to put my name.
i have seen that movie too, it does shock but i have a different take on the film. :)
about capital letters: lower case is easy. :)
formatting: i didnt quite get you here.
'in my ad': here too, i am lost.

9:40 PM

 
Blogger Sundar said...

both cry and shanta "cud" have av stuff too...
also fim maker ajay noronha-ex cry...he has done some interesting stuff on child sexual abuse in goa...i do rememebre him as a dedicated explorer in social issue space...dunno whether he has done nething on female infanticide though...
will keep my eyes open if i come across nething....

9:49 PM

 
Blogger poonam said...

sundar: thanks again.

11:36 AM

 
Blogger Sundar said...

looks like sania mirza is taking up cudgels on behalf of female infanticide..saw a mention during the HT leadership summit..shd do the cause some good..

11:45 PM

 
Blogger poonam said...

sundar: today morning, a filmmaker was telling me she read an article in IE or HT about involvement of some priests in the infanticide campaign. it's old news...coupla months old. if you come across anything, pls fwd the link on mail.

1:26 AM

 
Blogger Anon said...

Poonam;
by formating i ment...make it just a bit more easier on the eyes...
Also there is a line "....according to the senior who reviewed my ads" in the post...i was just interested to kow what the 'ad' in the line means.......

7:18 PM

 
Blogger poonam said...

komal: ad is short for advertisement. :)

3:22 AM

 
Blogger Sundar said...

have u looked at ifsha.org? i found it interesting...

7:01 PM

 
Blogger ajay noronha said...

Hi Poonam,
This is Ajay Noronha (Sundar's friend, we worked together at CRY some lifetimes ago). Any help I can be of, let me know. Cheers! - Ajay
Q. You Bombay based?

7:30 AM

 

Post a Comment

<< Home